My Undergraduate Anthology

Author: eohara (Page 17 of 30)

2QSQ #5 – 10/2/23

2QSQ #5 – 10:2:23

PART 1: PREPARING FOR DISCUSSION

SOURCE IDEAS:

“Do you think because I am poor, obscure, plain, and little, I am soulless and heartless? —You think wrong! — I have just as much soul as you, — and full as much heart! And if God had gifted me with some beauty, and much wealth, I should have made it as hard for you to leave me, as it is now for me to leave you. I am, not talking to you now through the medium of custom, conventionalities, nor even mortal flesh: it is my spirit that addresses your spirit; just as both had passed through the grave, and we stood at Gods feet, equal, — as we are!” (338).

“As regards the author’s chief object, however, it is a failure — that namely, of making a plain, odd woman, destitute of all the conventional features of feminine attraction, interesting in our sight. We deny that he has succeeded in this. Jane Eyre, in spite of some good things about her, is a being totally uncongenial to our feelings from beginning to end”.(592) — Rigby’s Quarterly Review, 1848.

SYNTHESIZING COMMENT/ANALYSIS:

With these two passages, I am thinking about how we might look into the public perception of Jane as both this beacon of feminist thinking of her time, full of questions and revolutionary thinking regarding social/class structures of England, and then this idea of her “unnatural” unearthly” connotations throughout the novel. This quote from chapter 23 is so poignant that I can’t pass it by without acknowledging it and just the sheer power it brings through the page. Not only is this an example of one of her moments where she truly speaks her mind, forgoing this ‘doctrine of endurance’ and is unashamedly bold, but think of the social conventions she alludes to that a poor, plain governess could speak in such a way to a wealthy, high-standing man. Looking at the argument Rigby makes in this review, they acknowledge how popular this book is — but immediately jump into naming all the reasons why it is dangerous. I am thinking of how this brings in our discussion of monster theory and the idea that there is such a lack of categorization implied within Jane and why these reviewers would feel she is just totally not relatable — shunned, so to speak, from the ‘conventional features of feminine attraction”. She is poor, an orphan, a woman — this is what is supposed to define her. Yet, she is the rightful inheritor of decent wealth, intelligent, and caught the attention of a conventionally superior man. She subverts so many of these boxes that gave the Victorian culture its order, and perhaps this could play into further discussion of Brontë’s choices to craft the novel in such a way where the interior of a person cannot fit in with this constructed society.

QUESTION:

Why do we think the public responded so greatly to Jane’s character and perhaps found these moments of rebellious thinking and redefining femininity so relatable, yet reviewers think her so unappealing? What might this say about this genre’s ability to generate a desire to live through this mysterious, thrilling, adventurous but not truly wishing to participate in its reality?

Drafty-Poem Project Exercise #2

Writing Reflection:

To start the reflection process of my writing for this project, I also should mention that I had a draft of this poem sitting in a journal from the middle of August – a very rough draft, more just some phrases and feelings – that I knew I wanted to write about and explore more fully, especially as I also tend to gravitate towards this writing around the turn of the seasons and my own self-reflection. For the first few drafts of the poem in the book, I stayed pretty close to my original day one entry with the ideas and structures and this emphasis on the heavy connections between the change of the season and the awareness of change within myself – growing up, different versions of youth, etc. But then I knew the emphasis wanted to be on the torn feeling of being in awe of the changes and this feeling that you cannot quite describe. That shifted me away from some of the really heavy, cliche-like phrases into more of a narrative questioning but still some natural imagery. As I moved from draft to draft over the course of the days, I found phrases that I liked and tried to incorporate them in different places within the poem and witnessed how they changed the meaning or reading of the poem. I still am not sure which version best encapsulates the feeling I had – and still have – but I do know that the themes and descriptors of nature and almost this existential awareness and longing can be universal throughout time but also can totally consume one singular moment.

Bookmaking Reflection:

For the bookmaking aspect of this project, I wanted to stick with primarily collage and then add a few emphasizing marks within the poem itself, but to keep it simple. For the imagery, I found some magazine clippings and photos I had in my vogues, New Yorker, etc., and just leafed through until I found something that hit the poem’s feeling. For one, this idea of seasons and nature seemed to play along with the essence of the poem and its drafts, where there is this subtle change but an apprehension to acknowledge it fully and to be conscious of the passage of time. For this, I chose the front and back covers to go together and be cohesive from start to end. There was this great set of an image where a bud was coupled with the word arrival and then a blooming flower labeled departure. I felt this was so evocative and played into my poem, where change doesn’t always mean gloom or decay but can actually indicate growth and a moment of reflection. Other elements, such as the pear and the greenery of trees, were very reminiscent of August and this almost past-ripe, souring of days at the end of summer to then the back cover showcasing a crisp change with more blues and oranges and also this emergence of a mountainous peak and the clock. Within the pages of the drafts themselves, I chose some colors, such as blues and greens, to embellish some of the key phrases or elements of each draft – also the spiraling leaves to match the words of the rustling leaves, some ocean doodles on the drafts with the ocean reference.

Final Poem:

Season’s End

And so, this simple thought just sitting,
asks why the night’s intoxicating luster
blinds us to the overripe morning
whose hour threatens to catch us.
What is it that just sits within yet cannot
clearly be defined through the murky
dew-soaked air.
For it is not sadness, joy, or fear,
and its peak – though never clearly seen –
invites the turn of the scene, each tired
rustle of the leaves chimes of wasted time

Drafty-Poem Exercise Reflections

Writing Reflection:

To start the reflection process of my writing for this project, I also should mention that I had a draft of this poem sitting in a journal from the middle of August – a very rough draft, more just some phrases and feelings – that I knew I wanted to write about and explore more fully, especially as I also tend to gravitate towards this writing around the turn of the seasons and my own self-reflection. For the first few drafts of the poem in the book, I stayed pretty close to my original day one entry with the ideas and structures and this emphasis on the heavy connections between the change of the season and the awareness of change within myself – growing up, different versions of youth, etc. But then I knew the emphasis wanted to be on the torn feeling of being in awe of the changes and this feeling that you cannot quite describe. That shifted me away from some of the really heavy, cliche-like phrases into more of a narrative questioning but still some natural imagery. As I moved from draft to draft over the course of the days, I found phrases that I liked and tried to incorporate them in different places within the poem and witnessed how they changed the meaning or reading of the poem. I still am not sure which version best encapsulates the feeling I had – and still have – but I do know that the themes and descriptors of nature and almost this existential awareness and longing can be universal throughout time but also can totally consume one singular moment.

Bookmaking Reflection:

For the bookmaking aspect of this project, I wanted to stick with primarily collage and then add a few emphasizing marks within the poem itself, but to keep it simple. For the imagery, I found some magazine clippings and photos I had in my vogues, New Yorker, etc., and just leafed through until I found something that hit the poem’s feeling. For one, this idea of seasons and nature seemed to play along with the essence of the poem and its drafts, where there is this subtle change but an apprehension to acknowledge it fully and to be conscious of the passage of time. For this, I chose the front and back covers to go together and be cohesive from start to end. There was this great set of an image where a bud was coupled with the word arrival and then a blooming flower labeled departure. I felt this was so evocative and played into my poem, where change doesn’t always mean gloom or decay but can actually indicate growth and a moment of reflection. Other elements, such as the pear and the greenery of trees, were very reminiscent of August and this almost past-ripe, souring of days at the end of summer to then the back cover showcasing a crisp change with more blues and oranges and also this emergence of a mountainous peak and the clock. Within the pages of the drafts themselves, I chose some colors, such as blues and greens, to embellish some of the key phrases or elements of each draft – also the spiraling leaves to match the words of the rustling leaves, some ocean doodles on the drafts with the ocean referenced, etc. 

2QSQ #4 – 9/25/23

O’Hara 2QSQ #4

PART 1: PREPARING FOR DISCUSSION

SOURCE IDEAS:

“All John Reed’s violent tyrannies, all his sisters’ proud indifference, all his mother’s aversions, all the servents’ partiality, turned up in my disturbed mind like a dark deposit in a turbid well. Why was I always suffering, always brow-beaten, always accused, for ever condemned? Why could I never please? Why was it useless to try to win anyone’s favour?” (Brontë 72).

“…this is a sad, a melancholy occasion; for it becomes my duty to warn you, that this girl, who might be one of God’s own lambs, is a little castaway: not a member of the true flock, but evidently am interloper and an alien. You must be on your guard against her; you must shun her example: if necessary, avoid her company, exclude her from your sports, and shut her out from your converse” (Brontë 129).

SYNTHESIZING COMMENT/ANALYSIS:

I found these two passages interesting as they can connect with the idea of how children could be seen as monstrous and also recognize the effect of Brontë’s choice of first-person narrative from the child themselves on how these outside forces of neglect and abuse affect her view of the world. Adhering to some of the characteristics of a monster from Cohen and Six & Tompson, we see themes surrounding neglect, being shunned from normative society, and even this idea of hierarchy and categorical confusion within the monster. However, the fact that these monstrous traits and reactions now relate to children feels quite different from our discussions of monsters within Frankenstein. Children within Shelley’s work were depicted with this angelic/purity, especially Victor’s youngest sibling, William. Then look to Brontë’s Jane Eyre, where we see Jane become aware of her differences and this almost uncontrollable effect she seems to have on those around her, adhering to some of our discussions of monsters. She feels isolated from the comforts of her society, with no companions or parental figures to love and guide her. Even within her home, she is repeatedly told that she does not have access to any of it. In this first quote, we see her grapple with ideas not so far off from the Creature as she cannot seem to understand why she invokes

such repulsion. Then, following Mr. Brocklehurst’s speech, where he publicly shuns Jane from her peers and any hopes of being accepted within her environment, it solidifies this connection of her being pushed into the ‘other’ within her world.

QUESTION:

Knowing a bit about Victorian gender roles and social hierarchy, I’m wondering to what extent we can bring these aspects of gender and class into themes of monsters. Being an orphan, Jane already doesn’t fit into the well-structured categories of Victorian families and social hierarchies — she is an outsider or a variable society now has to deal with. As a young girl, she continues to face even more pressure from society to adhere to those expectations — we see her being told to be more useful and pleasant, etc. Nonetheless, she is outspoken, resists these strict categories, and is an orphan. On top of these traits, perhaps we could connect them to the idea that monsters are dangerous because they are unpredictable; they do not fall into our well-ordered society — they defy classification.

Promotional Blurbs

"Hawthorne indeed produces the very essence of that wild and heathen forest, for I, too, remember the shaking of faith that desolate wilderness inspires with savage creatures lurking and howling in the cover of night. The path of those turning away from the glory of God and heaven above must then face the consequences of a snarled and evil road. As Heb. 3:12-13 reads, “Beware, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief in departing from the living God; but exhort one another daily, while it is called ‘Today,’ lest any of you be hardened through the deceitfulness of sin.” I only hope one’s readers take its truest meaning away from this dark tale – never dare to abandon one’s Puritan beliefs and the harmony of its community, for pre-destined are we each, and thou can never be too doubtful."

- Mary Rowlandson, author of A Narrative of the Captivity and Restauration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson
"I am proud beyond belief to read such a thrilling, well-crafted, and cautionary tale. While my great-grandson must have changed the spelling of our name to avoid the excess of fame following wherever he went –  as I cannot think of any other reason – he is right to look back on our family’s involvement in this dark hour of Salem. Indeed, this story shows the true level of darkness I encountered as I swiftly and relentlessly strove to oust Satan’s work as the highest court of the colonies and return that community to God. Some say I showed no remorse for those who dared to doubt my and God’s authority; I say look to Hawthorne’s description of that vital Puritain realization. With that dubious and ominous night that young Goodman Brown was initiated into the very heart of our religion – that those all aroud us may harbor the true nature of a foul and wicked sinner."

- Judge John Hathorne, great-grandfather of Nathaniel Hawthorne & leading judge in the Salem Witch Trials of 1692

Promotional Blurb Sources:

“Bible Gateway Passage: Hebrews 3:12-13 – New King James Version.” Bible Gateway, www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Hebrews+3%3A12- 13&version=NKJV. Accessed 29 Nov. 2023.

Brooks, Rebecca Beatrice, et al. “John Hathorne: Salem Witch Judge.” History of Massachusetts Blog, 24 Oct. 2021, historyofmassachusetts.org/john-hathorne-the-salem-witch-judge/. 

Tuttle, Jennifer. “Mary Rowlandson.”Writing, Revolution, and Resistance in US Literature. UNE Portfolio, https://eng200-a-s20.uneportfolio.org/2023/09/21/mary-rowlandson, Accessed 7 Dec. 2023.

Tuttle, Jennifer. “Nathaniel Hawthorne.”Writing, Revolution, and Resistance in US Literature. UNE Portfolio, https://eng200-a-s20.uneportfolio.org/nathaniel-hawthorne/, Accessed 7 Dec. 2023. 

« Older posts Newer posts »

© 2025 Elia's Site

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑

css.php